Pride vs Shame: tension needed for growth

Affect Regulation Theory: A Clinical Model (Norton Series on Interpersonal Neurobiology)
A recent article argues that we thrive in a natural tension between things and don’t do so well when we fall into a more simplified but ossified state. Think of Tronick’s messy interactions, in which the ongoing tension of break and repair is what builds a sense of self and resilience, but when one person is doing too much of the work (a parent trying to reach a child with challenges, or a child trying to reach to a depressed parent) things do not turn out so well. The latter are simpler but not healthier states. 

I wish I could recall who recently recommended the latest Norton Neuroscience book. It is superb. Dan Hill’s Affect Regulation Theory: A Clinical Model (Norton Series on Interpersonal Neurobiology) speaks to this important natural tension. Allan Schore did the forward. Don’t be fooled: while Schore and Hill hint the that the first part of the book is a review of Schore’s brilliant affect regulation books of the past, it is far more up to date and offers an elegant model of the central and natural tension between shame and pride that impacts the formation of attachment patterns early on through adulthood and does so in the context of dyadic work that me and my colleagues are accustomed to. I underlined a lot of pearls.

The discussions are an enlightening explication of attachment styles and personality, including different kinds of narcissism and borderline styles, and as such is very helpful in supporting good approaches to managing and helping people we work with every day. I was waiting to see if he deals with the individual differences that we see in SPD and ASD. He hinted he would. Even though he doesn’t this book provides a model for predicting the impact of such difficulties on the character style of the developing child. Very useful.

Author
Joshua Feder, M.D. Dr. Feder's Blog

You Might Also Enjoy...

ADHD and Life Expectancy with Russell Barkley, PhD

We interviewed ADHD icon Dr. Russ Barkley. I thought we'd hear about his groundbreaking work on behavioral interventions for ADHD. Instead, Dr. Barkley blew open our entire understanding of the impact of ADHD. Listen and let me know what you think!

Cannabis and Kids

Child psychiatrists are grappling with the problem of pervasive use of marijuana in an age where legalization of use for adults has led to even greater use in teens. In this episode, we go over two recent interviews in The Carlat Child Psychiatry Report.

Informed Consent - What Everyone Should Know

Informed consent is so much more than a quick signature on a form - it is an ongoing process that organizes medical care for doctors, patients, and families. This podcast covers the parts of informed consent process and a free download of a concise form.

Legislative Action: Chutes & Ladders

Getting a bill passed is a huge process. We cover a philosophy for 'fixing the world', the ups and downs of the legislative process, and managing meetings with important people. This is followed by a play by play on the bill we ran this cycle in 2019.

TMS for Kids?

Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS ) is getting a lot of attention and a lot of marketing. But is it safe and effective for children and adolescents? And if so, what's the cost and what should it be used for? Listen to my Carlat Podcast and find out.